Residential · NW Chicago Suburbs

Residential Roof Replacement in Illinois.

The right shingle. Installed right. Backed by a decade of warranty and an owner who’s on-site from first nail to final walkthrough.

Schedule an Estimate

About This Service

Once in a Lifetime.
Done Right.

25+

Year lifespan on quality installs

10

Year labor & material warranty

5★

Google rating every review

We don’t just put new shingles over old problems. Every replacement starts with a full inspection of the deck, attic, ventilation, and all flashings. If something is wrong underneath, we fix it before the new roof goes on.

Owner Mike Bartkovjaks has been on residential roofs across the NW Chicago suburbs since 2000. He is on-site for every replacement — not managing from an office. The person who assesses your roof is the person overseeing its replacement.

Five materials. One standard of work. No subcontracting.

What Illinois Winters Do to a Residential Roof

The NW Chicago suburbs have a specific climate fingerprint — and roofs here fail in predictable, Illinois-specific ways.

Ice Dam Damage

Heat escapes through the attic, melts snow at the ridge, refreezes at the cold eave — and backs water under the shingles. By the time you see a stain, the deck and insulation may already be compromised.

Granule Loss & UV Degradation

Illinois shingles take 25+ years of freeze-thaw cycling. Granule loss accelerates the breakdown — leaving the mat exposed. Heavy granules in gutters means the shingles are done.

Wind Uplift & Seal Failure

Illinois storms produce 60+ mph gusts. Older shingles lose their self-seal adhesion — making them vulnerable to lifting and blow-off. Seal failure on a 15+ year roof is usually a sign the whole surface is compromised.

Deck Rot from Chronic Leaks

Slow, unaddressed leaks at flashing points saturate the deck over years. Soft spots, spongy areas, and visible sagging indicate structural compromise. Surface re-shingling over rotted decking is wasted money.

Escalating Repair Costs

One patched section becomes two. Two becomes a recurring pattern every season. When repair costs are approaching 30–40% of replacement cost, the math favors a single, warranted replacement.

Age — The Quiet Risk

A 20+ year asphalt shingle roof that looks fine from the ground may be a single hail event away from widespread failure. An inspection at this age reveals the actual remaining life — before failure forces a rushed decision.

Exterior Services

Siding, Gutters & Exterior Repair Services

Your roof and exterior work together as a system. We handle everything above the foundation — siding, gutters, flashing, stucco, fascia, balconies, and more.

Asphalt Shingles

Architectural and dimensional profiles. Class 4 impact-rated options for hail resistance and potential insurance discounts. 25–30 year lifespan.

Custom Metal

Standing seam systems fabricated in-house. Handles freeze-thaw cycles exceptionally well. 50+ year lifespan. We manufacture all flashings and details.

Natural & Synthetic Slate

Natural slate for historic and luxury homes. Synthetic slate for the look without the weight. Both installed with full custom metal flashing systems.

Clay Tile

Spanish tile, mission tile, and custom clay profiles. Quality tile sourced with proper underlayment and custom-fabricated metal details for Illinois freeze-thaw performance.

Copper

Bay window roofs, accent sections, and architectural details. Hand-fabricated on-site. Develops a natural patina over time. Very few local contractors offer this.

How It Works

Simple from First Call to Final Inspection

No complicated intake process. No waiting weeks for a quote. We make it easy to get started.

1

Inspection & Estimate

Deck, attic, ventilation, and all flashing points assessed. Written estimate with material options and pricing — before anything is scheduled.

2

Material Selection

We walk you through profiles, colors, and impact ratings suited to your home and Illinois climate. No upsells — the right material for the application.

3

Tear-Off & Deck Repair

Full tear-off of old materials. Deck inspected for rot or damage and repaired before anything goes back on. Owner on-site throughout.

4

Install & Warranty

Installation to manufacturer spec. Owner-led final walkthrough. Full 10-year labor and material warranty documentation handed over before we leave.

What's Underneath

We Fix What's
Below Before
Anything Goes On Top.

01

Full deck inspection after tear-off

We inspect every square foot of sheathing after old material is removed. Soft spots, rot, and water damage are repaired before any new material is installed.

02

Ventilation corrected if needed

Poor attic ventilation cuts shingle life in half and drives ice dam formation. We check and correct intake/exhaust balance on every job — not just the roof surface.

03

Ice-and-water shield at every eave

Illinois eaves need proper ice-and-water shield — not just synthetic felt. We never skip it. Every vulnerable edge is protected before shingles go on.

04

Custom-fabricated flashing at every penetration

Chimney, dormers, skylights, pipe boots — all flashing cut and formed in-house. The surface is only as good as the seals beneath it.

Questions

Replacement FAQ

What homeowners ask before getting an estimate.

How long does a residential roof replacement take in Illinois?

Most residential replacements complete in 1–2 days. Larger homes or specialty materials like slate and copper may take 3–5 days. We confirm the exact timeline in your written estimate before scheduling — no vague start dates.

Asphalt shingle replacements typically range from $8,000–$18,000 for average Illinois homes. Metal, slate, clay tile, and copper systems are priced higher based on material and complexity. We provide detailed, itemized estimates so you know exactly what you’re paying before committing to anything.

Architectural asphalt shingles rated for high wind and impact resistance are the most cost-effective choice for most Illinois homes. For premium longevity, standing seam metal roofing handles freeze-thaw cycles exceptionally well and lasts 50+ years. We’ll recommend the right material for your home, budget, and weather exposure during your estimate.

Yes. Severe or repeated ice dam damage can compromise the deck, underlayment, and insulation to the point where full replacement is more cost-effective than repairs. We inspect the full system during your estimate to give you an honest picture of what’s underneath — not just what’s visible on the surface.

What Clients Say

Real homeowners. Real completed projects. No paid ratings.

Posted on Google Google
Ed Taleysnik profile picture
Ed Taleysnik
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I can’t recommend enough working with **Black Square Roofing & Exterior, Inc.** and especially Mark. From start to finish, the experience was outstanding. The quality of work speaks for itself — every detail was handled with incredible care, precision, and professionalism. What truly sets Mark apart is his passion for perfection. He treats every project like it’s his own and never cuts corners. His attention to detail, communication, and commitment to doing things the right way made the entire process stress-free and enjoyable. Beyond being a true professional, Mark has also been a great friend and trusted partner to **Bravo Theater**. It’s rare to find someone who combines craftsmanship, integrity, and genuine care for their clients the way he does. If you’re looking for a company that delivers exceptional results and stands behind their work, Black Square Roofing & Exterior, Inc. is the one to call. Highly recommended!
Posted on Google Google
Daniela Cwajbaum profile picture
Daniela Cwajbaum
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
A great job, on time and reasonable price. Highly recommend!
Posted on Google Google
anton madalli profile picture
anton madalli
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We just had our roof done last week, and Mark managed the entire project. He even helped us with the design, which turned out great. On top of that, his guys noticed that our backyard sliding door wasn’t working properly and helped fix it on the spot. Way to go, guys — we will definitely recommend your business!
Posted on Google Google
Gene V profile picture
Gene V
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Mark was recommended to me by a contractor about 12 years ago. He replaced my room and gutters, ant the time I didn't know much about "good or bad" roof, but when I was selling my house few years later, I heart one of the realtors (he told me later that he used to be a roofer) tell his clients that rood on that house is done so well that it will outleave that house (and it was a brick ranch that wasn'tgoing anywherewith the next storm). When I purchased a new house, it had a "new" roof that was done by the company recommended by insurance adjuster. About a year after moving in I started heaving problems with it (my chimney was leaking, piece of plywood on my garage roof rotted out...) he was always there for me as soon as I called, and everything was done the right way. ( Saving money now for the new roof in siding, so Mark can get it done and I can forget about it forever)
Posted on Google Google
Robert Marshal profile picture
Robert Marshal
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Really good work appreciate your work!!!
Posted on Google Google
Stepan Kobzey profile picture
Stepan Kobzey
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Mark and his team did a great job fixing my roof after issues left by a previous contractor. They repaired problems with the stucco wall, properly installed flashing where it had been done incorrectly before by a different contractor, and removed and replaced rotten wood siding, custom-cut to the correct length and width. They also resolved a long-running issue with the balconies where water was getting into the house, replacing the rotten flooring with composite material. Communication was clear, they explained everything along the way, and were very professional. Highly recommend.
Posted on Google Google
Eugene Fox profile picture
Eugene Fox
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Have used them on several occasions - from regular house repairs (roofing and exterior) to dealing with major hail storm consequences. Can't say enough good things. The owner and his crews work with highest quality and unparalleled attention to detail. Owner has decades of experience in this area and is able to help with making right decisions without upsell. Cannot recommend this business high enough.

Arlington Heights, IL & NW Chicago Suburbs

Ready to Replace Your Home's Roof?
Let's Talk.

No pressure. No obligation. An honest estimate from an owner who has been replacing residential roofs across the NW suburbs since 2007.

Contact Us

More Roof Replacemen Guides

Straight answers on lifespans, costs, and warning signs.

Aerial view of a white reflective low-slope roof that rejects solar heat instead of absorbing it
Commercial Roofing

Cool Roofs & Reflective Flat Roofing

A dark low-slope roof in full July sun runs far hotter than the air around it, and your air conditioning pays for the difference every hour. A reflective roof sends most of that energy back. The EPA puts the reduction in peak cooling demand at 11 to 27% — and in the City of Chicago, reflective covering isn’t optional on

Read More »
Home with rooftop solar over a slate roof in the Chicago suburbs
Roofing Materials

Solar Shingles: Worth It on a Chicago Roof?

The economics of residential solar changed on January 1, 2026, and a lot of the advice still circulating hasn’t caught up. The 30% federal tax credit for homeowner-owned systems is gone. That doesn’t make solar shingles a bad idea in Chicago — but it changes the math enough that you should redo it. Here’s the honest version, from a roofer

Read More »
New architectural asphalt shingle roof and copper chimney flashing on an Arlington Heights home
Roof Replacement

Are Class 4 Impact-Resistant Shingles Worth It in Illinois?

State Farm paid $558 million in Illinois hail claims in 2025 — third-most of any state — and Illinois has logged more than 500 hail reports so far in 2026, fourth-most in the country. That turns impact-resistant shingles from a national trend piece into a local math problem: does the upgrade pay for itself here? Usually yes, but not for

Read More »
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.